Skip to content
OCRV Center
Home

Two Calculations Worth Doing Before You Authorize Anything

Written by Fleet Account Manager, Fleet and Commercial Account Manager, OCRV Center. Reviewed by Claims Coordinator

In shortTwo tools. One weighs repair against replacement on a damaged unit. The other converts shop days into money your operation actually loses. Neither produces a quotation, and neither replaces an inspection.

How do I decide whether to repair or replace a damaged RV?

Compare the repair range against what the unit is worth and what a comparable replacement costs, then add what the downtime costs you. The calculator on this OCRV Center page structures that comparison using the posted Yorba Linda labor rates. It produces a range for discussion, never a quotation.

  • Inputs are your figures: value, replacement cost, damage areas, daily loss
  • Labor hours come from documented job bands, not from a guess
  • Output is a range with a decision threshold, not a price
  • A written estimate at $150 is what turns a range into a number
Tools on this page
2Repair against replace, and downtime cost per day
Rates used
$210 and $260 per hourBody and paint, mechanical and electrical
Output type
RangeNever a quotation and never binding
What replaces it
$150 written estimateCredited in full against an authorized repair
Where inspection happens
In shopAt the Yorba Linda facility only

Last verified

Two questions decide most large repairs and owners usually answer them in the wrong order. Is this unit worth repairing, and what is it costing me while it is not working. The second question is the one people skip, and on a working vehicle it is frequently larger than the repair itself.

These calculators structure both. They do not price your repair, because nobody can price a laminated sidewall from a form. What they do is stop you comparing a repair number against nothing, which is how a coach ends up sold for half its value or a work van sits for three weeks over a decision that should have taken a day.

01

Calculator one: repair weighed against replacement

The first tool asks what the unit is worth today, what a comparable replacement would actually cost you including tax and transfer, and which areas are damaged. From the damaged areas it assembles a labor hour range using the documented bands for those job classes, applies the posted rate for the department that owns each one, and adds parts and materials as a proportion rather than as a guess at specific part numbers.

What comes out is two ranges side by side and a threshold. Below the threshold, repair is straightforwardly better. Above it, the decision turns on things a calculator cannot see: whether the unit has a custom build in it, whether a replacement is even available in your configuration, and whether your policy is written on agreed value or on actual cash value. Those are the cases where the number is a starting point for a conversation instead of an answer.

  • Inputs: current value, realistic replacement cost, damaged areas, age
  • Optional inputs: custom build value, agreed value policy, prior repair history
  • Hours come from documented job bands rather than from an average
  • Rates applied per department: $210 body and paint, $260 mechanical and electrical
  • Output: a repair range, a replacement range and the threshold between them
02

Calculator two: what a day out of service costs

The downtime tool exists because operators consistently underestimate this figure, and because insurers rarely pay it. You supply the daily numbers, since only you know them: revenue the unit produces on a working day, whatever it costs you to substitute for it, the labor you are paying regardless, and any contractual penalty for missing a date. The tool multiplies that across a shop day range and shows the total against the repair range from the first calculator.

The output changes decisions more often than the repair number does. A three day difference in turnaround is trivial on a personal coach and decisive on a food truck. Once the daily figure is written down, parts strategy becomes obvious: ordering ahead of teardown, accepting a serviceable used panel, or staging two units instead of four stops being a preference and becomes arithmetic.

  • Inputs: daily revenue, substitution cost, fixed labor, contractual penalties
  • Multiplied across a shop day range rather than a single optimistic date
  • Shown beside the repair range so the two can be compared directly
  • Useful for deciding whether to pay for expedited parts
03

What to have in front of you before you start

Both tools work better with paperwork than with memory. Five minutes of gathering produces a result worth acting on, and guessing produces a result that feels precise and is not. If you do not have a figure, leave it blank rather than inventing one, because a blank input widens the output range honestly while a wrong input narrows it dishonestly.

  1. Year, make, model and length of the unit, plus the chassis if it is a motorhome.
  2. A current value figure from a valuation source or a recent comparable sale.
  3. Your declarations page: deductible, and whether the policy is agreed value or actual cash value.
  4. A list of damaged areas by location rather than by guessed part name.
  5. For a working vehicle, your own daily revenue and substitution figures.
  6. Any prior repair history on the same area, which changes both scope and coverage.
04

How to read the output without misreading it

The result is a range and the width of the range is information. A narrow range means the job class is predictable: a seal, a panel, an appliance. A wide range means the scope depends on what is behind something, which is the normal condition for water damage, delamination and any impact near a slide opening. A wide range is not the tool hedging. It is the tool telling you that teardown will decide the number.

What the output is not is a quotation, and nothing on this page becomes binding. The document that gets authorized is a written repair estimate produced with the unit on the floor, which costs $150 and is credited in full against an authorized repair. Where the fault has not been identified yet, a diagnostic at $285 per hour with a one hour minimum comes first, also credited.

05

Where the calculator gets its numbers

Labor hours come from the documented bands on the job pages, which were written from repair orders rather than from a published time guide. Rates come from the posted card: $210 for body and paint, $260 for mechanical and electrical, $285 for diagnostics with a one hour minimum, $95 for detail. Materials follow the published formulas and parts follow the published markup, so the arithmetic inside the tool matches the arithmetic on an invoice.

Nothing about your unit is invented. If a damaged area maps to a job class we have not documented, the tool says so rather than substituting something similar. That is deliberate: a calculator that always produces a confident answer is a calculator that is sometimes confidently wrong, and on a five figure decision that is worse than an honest gap.

06

What neither calculator can tell you

It cannot see behind a panel. Hidden decking rot, a subfloor that has delaminated under vinyl, corrosion on a subframe under a slide room: all of those change a scope substantially and none of them are visible from a form. It also cannot tell you what your carrier will approve, because that decision belongs to an adjuster reading a policy you signed.

And it cannot come to you. Every inspection that turns a range into a number happens in shop at Yorba Linda, because we do not offer mobile repair and there is no roadside option. If the unit will not move, the tool is still useful for deciding whether a tow is worth paying for, which on a large repair it usually is.

Appendix

Appendix: questions and answers

Will this calculator give me a firm price for my repair?
No, and any tool claiming to is guessing. It produces a range built from documented labor bands and the posted hourly rates. The document that becomes a price is a written repair estimate produced with the unit on the floor, at $150, credited in full if you authorize the work. The range is for deciding, not for paying.
What information do I need before I start entering figures?
Year, make, model and length; a current value figure; your declarations page for the deductible and valuation basis; and a list of damaged areas by location. For a working vehicle add your daily revenue and substitution costs. Leave anything you do not know blank, because a guessed input produces a falsely narrow answer.
How do I work out what one day out of service costs my business?
Add the revenue the unit earns on a working day, the cost of substituting for it, the wages you pay regardless, and any penalty for missing a contracted date. Most operators find the total is larger than they assumed, which is usually what justifies ordering parts ahead of teardown rather than after it.
The result leans toward replacement but I want to keep the unit. What then?
That is a legitimate position and the arithmetic does not overrule it. Custom builds, discontinued layouts and units bought for a specific purpose are frequently worth repairing past the point a spreadsheet approves. Bring the unit in, get the scope measured, and decide against a real number rather than a modelled one.
Next step

Open a file on this repair

Tell us the vehicle, what happened and whether a claim is open. We will tell you what the scope looks like and what it takes to get you back on the road.